made of / made from

oversky

made of / made from 的用法应该算是常见的考题。
/ W0 |8 r& v" d但是今天查 suit 这个辞，发现有的辞典是用 made of ， 有的辞典是用 made from。
) m. R% {( {: o" X1 p是不是实用上并没有那么严格区分？
: T1 v  H, W/ }- B9 b3 X
* `2 I7 c% K5 Q2 {: Chttps://www.oxfordlearnersdictio ... glish/suit_1?q=suit
a set of clothes made of the same cloth, including a jacket and trousers/pants or a skirt

2 L3 k6 ?. F6 M* L% ?0 O8 rhttps://www.ldoceonline.com/dictionary/suit
a set of clothes made of the same material, usually including a jacket with trousers or a skirt
8 {9 G  n; q) R' \8 t; q# c/ P

https://www.macmillandictionary.com/dictionary/british/suit_2
a set of clothes made from the same cloth, usually a jacket with trousers or a skirt

https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/suit
a jacket and trousers or a jacket and skirt that are made from the same material:

4 u3 a; I; x: a7 x1 D; F- S6 x+ D
+ z2 b* k; Q' O1 ?: I( W+ i- L

klwo2

看这个：https://english.stackexchange.co ... de-from-and-made-of
4 @2 `+ j( x6 n- _" p9 }
0 ~6 m* S% c" |' n* ~2 T, w1 |5 [简而言之就是，有区别，可是区分得不严格，不遵守也没事儿

! d+ K2 B) ]8 z5 Q7 i

elusty

4 C% \8 o% K4 ^& hmade from 强调制造方式；
made of 强调物品的基本构成：Coach Shane专门有一期讲解了四个词：made of, made from, made out of, made with.
+ @& W, p( ~1 B9 }/ J' q他说，日常生活中，很多人是不分的。
我们平时说的是否改变形状和外观的from和of，他也提到了，是一个规则。

% v% ]/ }! v# u: P& b: ~( _剑桥：
Made from
$ f( q5 Y1 |; d" y( u+ {

We often use made from when we talk about how something is manufactured:

Plastic is made from oil.

The earliest canoes were made from tree trunks.

" I4 f5 B9 G# f2 }
" {% P, E+ P8 x# ]! g: x
1 P4 [5 ]4 m6 F7 C5 I" _9 _Made of

We use made of when we talk about the basic material or qualities of something. It has a meaning similar to ‘composed of’:

She wore a beautiful necklace made of silver.

# i% Z0 k; o3 \, H. L. O
: t) p4 v/ p4 ?7 C& D) n

freecomic101

葛传椝英语惯用法词典 make 词条
# v; Z2 k9 \7 |& c! D0 B

4. 说“把（原料）做成（东西）”，假使那原料并不变化得看不出原料，那表示原料的词的前面用 of，否则用 from，如 We make tables of wood 和 We make paper from rags。木材做成了桌子仍旧看得出是木材，但破布做成了纸便看不出是破布了。这里所说的“变化得看不出原料”，仔细想来，没有绝对的标准，如把面粉做成了馒头，不能断定是否“变化得看不出原料”，在这种情形用 of 或 from 都可以。  
: g& ^* _/ l+ P4 U7 l不用 of 或 from 而用 out of，便加重了语气。

0 V: p6 f4 u& @9 p) p! Q
9 Y/ l0 S( A2 [  k
2 q9 K- n2 K* M) U% w

cocowind

. q1 P1 K% e8 f
1 d& D1 p) n1 R, t# q( ]. O

' c5 J& A# z0 U% z; uMichael Swan_牛津英语用法指南（新版）_斯旺著_外语教学与研究出版社_2010
5 D/ N) T7 B. J2 S1 ~) x+ Y

wpa

elusty 发表于 2019-7-1 20:29
made from 强调制造方式；
made of 强调物品的基本构成：Coach Shane专门有一期讲解了四个词：made of, mad ...

( g" n+ h9 y5 P/ X我也看CS 的，这个是在口语的那块，还是听力的那块？

elusty

wpa 发表于 2019-7-2 15:23
我也看CS 的，这个是在口语的那块，还是听力的那块？

我是在油管上看到的：https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UAc5yO9ONIA
另外，还有他的博客：http://0english.blogspot.com/2012/12/ec1-quiz-answers-how-to-use-made-of.html
) ^* _7 P  q, T9 J
///////////////////
The week's challenge was HOW TO USE:

made of ~
. h: _( l8 f2 {% F, }7 |made from ~
made with ~
, E6 M' l' H! W% R$ |# G/ B9 Amade out of ~

The answer: Most native English speakers do NOT distinguish. We mix them up. BUT, there are some rules:
$ N2 _( j+ \- a5 w
2 e1 s- W5 f( l
Made of ~ does not change form (house—still bricks, shirt—still cotton)
0 |- B. d3 z) t6 s4 IMade from ~ changes form (paper from trees, wine from grapes)  
                     (cannot reconstitute--cannot go back to trees/grapes)
  z8 \5 O+ r) h% P6 |4 }Made with ~ care/love/meaning OR a mixture (A cake is made with eggs,
# p$ w3 W1 P* I% v1 j' a5 R9 v                     flour, butter, sugar)
Made out of ~ the source (especially ONE source/ingredient)—
4 X+ B, w7 H) i, h                     wine/cotton/plastic/wood. My remote control is made out of
                     plastic.


* Z  a' G9 F3 P5 \$ @
1 a* }* k/ h$ e" e- M# u' t# y) `It's a little confusing. And in most situations, more than one answer is possible. But NOT always!

( ~" s. j5 i, m5 ?2 k/ gThe answers to the QUIZ at the end of the video:  I have chosen the BEST answer first^^

4 o# M  i$ @3 O# }5 o' x8 G5 w1. Orange juice is made out of oranges.  (Also "from" is possible.)

3 }3 y) N& ^' T" V- s0 q2. This house is made of wood. ("out of" and "with" are also possible)

7 e& N" P/ |3 A$ ]+ E

6 |) ^( ^( G6 q9 G) K% p3. This dress is made of silk. ("out of" is also possible)
' F$ y2 v$ Y8 i7 v+ \+ L) F

3 |, C# W$ R# j) T4 D0 q+ W1 A
9 k/ Y5 T! t1 L3 a4. This house is made of trees. ("out of" is also possible)
4 H5 n) t* u9 h2 h9 O

3 R4 H0 b+ Y% \# W: R3 p
5. This soup is made with chicken.

6. This sandwich is made with cheese.
3 r; M: N% K( f, u6 D! I
/ z. @; J% i8 a5 y. C

7. This sidewalk is made from old tires. ("out of" is also possible)
+ n9 O: {; R# S

" K1 F& j4 E8 J8 h8 j% [
8. This statue is made out of marble. ("of" is also possible)

7 O( F* e9 K; q) v5 Q9. These Christmas cards are made with love.

, B; W. U& p8 A! L" Z

  P7 n$ J+ ~' H0 M# b' l$ b
: B9 c2 V. X4 H  V, B; o10. Ice cream is made with cream. ("from" and "out of" are also possible)